Bach Cello Suites
Bach Cello Suites
Should we perform Bach's cello suites as barque performers would?
this is NOT HOMEWORK I would just like to know
then I can use this research in my AS exam to back up my evidence
thnkooooooo
=D
There are two paradigms set up here, one by Wanda Landowski and the other by Glenn Gould.
Gould looked at Bach's music and saw in it the need to carry out the composers intent. Something that could not be done if a performer limited themselves to the capabilities and techniques of the baroque. Revitalizing the psychological and emotional impact that the composer intended was more important than playing the notes exactly as they would have been done 250 years ago. If you don't change things, then the music becomes a pedantic relic.
Wanda Landowski (one of the pioneers of historical performance) made the opposite conclusions. The intent of the composer was best understood only if the music was played within the parameters understood by the composer. If you start changing things then you can't help but change the composers intent.
So who's right? I think there's a third option as proposed by Edward T. Cone. We should think of a composition not as sculpture already set in stone with only one interpretive route, but instead think of a composition as a blueprint; a means of suggesting to performers any number of possible interpretations.
Here are some books and articles to look up for further reading:
Edward T. Cone: In the Gallery
John Butt: Playing with history: the historical approach to musical performance
Mark Franko, Annette Richards: Acting on the Past: Historical Performance Across the Disciplines
 |
 Esther Nyffenegger BACH 6 Suites Cello 3LP BOX HOLY GRAIL  US $1,599.99
|
 BACH 6 Suites for Cello Solo ERLING BLØNDAL BENGTSSON Danacord DACO 226 8 RARE US $995.00
|
 JS BACH 6 Cello Suites MISCHA MAISKY DGG 415 416 1 dig 1985 LP US $795.00
|
 BACH Cello Suites 34 ENRICO MAINARDI Archiv 14044 APM US $795.00
|
 Janos Starker Bach Solo Cello Suites Mercury Stereo SR3 9016 US $750.00
|
 AUGUST WENZINGER BACH Cello Suites BAREN REITER 3 LP US $750.00
|
 BACH Cello Suites 12 ENRICO MAINARDI Archiv 14029 APM US $745.00
|
 JANOS STARKER BACH SUITES FOR UNACCOMPANIED CELLO COMPLETE 3 LP MONO OL3 116 US $550.00
|
 RENAUD FONTANAROSA Bach cello solo suites french STEREO Box US $545.00
|
 BACH 6 Cello Suites HENRI HONEGGER Telefunken US $475.00
|
 BACH The 6 Suites for Cello Solo MISCHA MAISKY GER 85 DG DIGITAL 3 LP BOX NM US $430.00
|
 MAURICE GENDRON bach unaccompanied cello 3 LP VG US $400.00
|
 BACH 6 Cello Suites REINE FLACHOT Intercord 2 LPs NM US $395.00
|
 Last Recording LP Fournier Bach Cello Suite1976same to Fr Festival SetRare US $369.99
|
 STARKER Bach Solo Cello Suites 1 3 UK COLUMBIA 33CX 1656 EX US $350.00
|
 PABLO CASALS Bach SUITES FOR CELLO UNACCOMPANIED EMI ANGEL UKCOLH 161718 US $250.00
|
 RARE JULIUS BERGER BACH 6 CELLO SUITES SOLO ORFEO 3LP US $250.00
|
 ED1 VEDERNIKOV Piano BACH English Suites 1 2 MELODIYA GOST 5289 73 Free SHIP US $210.00
|
 MIKLOS PERENYI BACH 6 UNACCOMPANIED CELLO 1991 3LP PRO MINT Unplayed US $199.99
|
 BACH ENRICO MAINARDI 6 CELLO SUITES EURODISC 3 LP US $199.99
|
 MAURICE GENDRON BACH CELLO SUITES STEREO BOX SET US $199.99
|
 RARE FIRST PRESSING MAINARDI BACH CELLO SUITES MONO LP US $199.99
|
 31 LP classical music including numerous famous classical musicians US $199.99
|
 SHAFRAN DANIEL Bach Suites Solo 13 MEL CM01935 MINT US $199.00
|
 GENDRON BACH 6 Cello Suites PHILIPS MONO ED1 3LP NM US $195.00
|
 SHAFRAN Bach Cello Suites Solo 13 MEL CM01935 MINT US $180.00
|
 Janos Starker Bach 6 Cello Suites 3x 180g LP Boxset US $161.22
|
 Janos Starker Bach 6 Cello Suites 180 Gram 33rpm Sealed Vinyl 3LP Box Set US $159.99
|
 FREDERICK ZLOTKIN BACH 6 SUITES FOR CELLO SOLO MHS 3LP US $150.00
|
 3LP Box BLUE Label BACH 6 Sonatas Partitas For Violin Solo PIKAIZEN Free SHIP US $150.00
|
 ANNER BIJLSMA JS BACH CELLO SUITES STEREO BOX SET US $149.99
|
 BACH CELLO SUITES 1 6 PAUL TORTELIER EMI SLS 798 US $145.00
|
 BACH Les 6 Suites pour Violoncelle seul EMI C153 00892 4 3 LPs CELLO SUITES US $135.00
|
 PIERRE FOURNIER cello BACH Six Solo Cello Suites 3LP US $109.99
|
 Janos Starker Bach Suites for Cello Speakers Corner 3LP Box Set NEW SEALED US $109.99
|
 Daniel SHAFRAN BACH Six Suites For Solo Cello MELODIYA BLUE STEREO 1974 3LP US $105.50
|
 BACH SUITES FOR CELLO UNACCOMPANIED COMPLETE GENDRON 2L US $100.00
|
 Bach Cello Suites Starker Mercury Golden Imports 3 record box set US $160.00
|
 MAURICE GENDRON BACH Cello Suites PHILIPS 3lp NM US $99.00
|
 BACH Suites f Cello Solo 1 6 HEINRICH SCHIFF EMI dig US $95.00
|
 NM SIGNED LILI KRAUS 12 lp Box Mozart Complete Piano Concerti NM US $95.00
|
 BIZET LArlesienne Carmen Suites WALLBERG Columbia STEREO B S NO SAX Free SH US $92.00
|
 YO YO MA bach unaccompanied cello 1983 3 lp set US $89.99
|
 ULTRA RARE GERMAN 3 LPS SET FOURNIER BACH SOLO CELLO SUITES US $89.99
|
 MURRAY HILL 3 LPs S 47593 Pablo Casals in Concert Various OOP USA 1972 NM US $84.99
|
 RED STEREO FOURNIER BACH SUITES 1 2 ARCHIV LP US $79.99
|
 RARE NEW OLD STOCK JS BACH SUITES SWISS ONLY LP US $79.99
|
 SEALED Lot of 12 OST SHERLOCK HOLMES Soundtracks Basil Rathbone Murray Hill US $79.95
|
 CASALS Six Suites Cello Solo Nos1 6 BWV 1007 1012 3LPs US $79.02
|
 BACH Sonata for Violin Solo BWV 1001 Partita 1004 KOLUNDZIJA Live 1985 Recording US $79.00
|
 Yo Yo Ma Bach Unaccompanied Cello Suites Volume One 1 2 LP Inner CBS US $76.46
|
 P Casals Bach s1 6 Cello Solo 3 LPs UNPL US $75.00
|
 PIERRE FOURNIER BACH Violoncello Solo No 5 6 ARCHIV US $75.00
|
 PABLO CASALS BACH Suites for Unaccompanied Cello 3 4 COLH 17 Mono Solo US $71.99
|
 PABLO CASALS BACH Suites for Unaccompanied Cello 12 COLH 16 Mono Solo US $71.99
|
 PABLO CASALS BACH Suites for Unaccompanied Cello56 COLH 18 Mono Solo US $71.99
|
 cello PABLO CASALS 3LP Bach Six Suites MELODIYA US $69.99
|
 ARCHIV 198188 BACH Cello suite 56 FOURNIER red stereo US $69.00
|
 LP Mercury stereo Bach Suites Cello Starker MINT US $63.45
|
 LP box set Casals 6 Suites for Cello by Bach Angel rec US $63.21
|
 BACH Cello Suites 12 ENRICO MAINARDI SOLO EURODISC ISRAEL LP US $60.00
|
 LONDON LLP 144 LP BACH Brandenburg Conc No 4 6 Munchinger Barchet 1949 US $59.99
|
 FREDERICK ZLOTKIN BACH Six Suites for Solo Cello MHS 3 LP Stereo Box Set NM US $59.95
|
 NM Mozart Sonatas Violin Pianoforte William Kroll Balsam LOiseau Lyre Stereo US $55.00
|
 EMI 3LP CASALS Cello BACH BOCCHERINI BRAHMS MENDELSSOHN SCHUMANN Free Shipping US $52.00
|
 Audiophile 45rpm LP APPROCHE AP 5 LOCKE Consort VIOLES of OXENFORD Free SHIPPING US $50.00
|
 BACH SOLO CELLO SUITES 3 4 PIERRE FOURNIER ARCHIV SUPERB LP US $50.00
|
 ANTONIO JANIGRO BACH Suites For Solo Cello 2 6 WESTMINISTER NM US $49.99
|
 JANOS STARKER Bach Suites MERCURY 50370 {dg orig} RARE US $49.99
|
 PHILIPPE MULLER BACH UNACCOMPANIED CELLO SUITE 3 CARMIRELLI VIOLIN CHACONNE US $49.00
|
 BACH 6 French Suites BWV 812 817 RUZICKOVA Harpsichord 2LP STEREO Free Shipping US $49.00
|
 Casals Bach Suites for Solo Cello Nos 2 3 RCA LCT 1104 US $48.75
|
 CasalsPablo celloBachSuites For violincello solo I II III LP M M US $48.00
|
 2LP Box GOULD Piano BACH 6 English Suites CBS 79208 STEREO NM Free Shipping US $48.00
|
 HM 381 383 JSBACH THE 6 SUITES FOR SOLO CELLO NIKOLAUS HARNCOURT 3 LP US $47.41
|
 P FOURNIER Bach Sts 5 6 Archive 198 188 NM US $45.00
|
 BACH Cello Suites 56 JORG BAUMANN Teldec AUDIOPHILE US $45.00
|
 3 lp Box Brunner Markus Passion Knall Collegium Musicum Ex Libris EL 16985 NM US $45.00
|
 2lp Schubert Winterreise Hermann Prey Philippe Bianconi PCM Digital OB 7399 7400 US $45.00
|
 SEALED Strauss CELLO Sonata Beethoven Variations Rostropovich Devetzi RL 32012 US $45.00
|
 Demonstration Record Sample ANSERMET BEETHOVEN 9th Symphony STS 15089 N US $45.00
|
 REVIEW COPY FALLA ARGENTA Espana El Retablo de Maese Pedro NM US $45.00
|
 ANTONIO JANIGRO DIXON DVORAK CELLO Con Westminster WL 5225 US 53 US $45.00
|
 NM French Music Pavane Apprenti Sorcier PHILIPS DIGITAL STEREO 412 131 Marriner US $45.00
|
 2 lp Wolf Italienisches Liederbuch Erna Berger soprano w Prey Electrola NM US $45.00
|
 4 x 12 78 rpm BLOCH Concerto for VIOLIN Joseph SZIGETI MUNCH Paris SET M 380 US $45.00
|
 2 Vintage PAUL MAUD TORTELIER CELLO lps 10 BLP Elgar Con 1959 Supraphon LPV US $45.00
|
 FOURNIER BACH SUTTEN VIOLONCELLO SOLO ARCHIV PROD 198186 GERMANY MINT RARE FIND US $45.00
|
 4 lp Box Russian Boshoi Borodin PRINCE IGOR Melik Pashayev MK 05322 29 US $45.00
|
 3 78 rpm RCA 12 Efrem KURTZ Chopin CELLO Sonatas w Balsam Piano DM 1322 NM US $45.00
|
 2 lp Box BACH Six Clavier Partitas AGI JAMBOR piano Capitol PBR 8354 US $45.00
|
 PIERRE FOURNIER CELLO Elgar Bloch Orig DGG Tulip 139128 US $45.00
|
 SCHUBERT Trout Vienna Konzerthaus Qrt Badura Skoda Westminster XWN 18264 NM US $45.00
|
 2 NM Unplayed Joerg DEMUS Schumann Mozart Piano lps Westminster XWN US $45.00
|
 Lot of 13 Paul BADURA SKODA PIANO lps Bach Beethoven Westminster WL XWN WST US $45.00
|
 Lot of 3 NM Remington lps Unplayed NM Berlioz Stravinsky Prokofiev Grieg US $45.00
|
 NM Zelenka Munclinger ARS Rediviva Ensemble Supraphon SUA ST 59561 US $45.00
|
|
Bach: Cello Suites US$ 23.72 Disc 1:
|
|
Bach: Cello Suites US$ 18.18 Disc 1:
|
|
Bach: Cello Suites US$ 12.26 Disc 1:
|
|
Bach: Cello Suites US$ 22.65 Description not available. |
|
Gemini - Bach: Cello Suites / Schiff US$ 12.19 Disc 1:
|
|
Bach: Cello Suites / Anne Gastinel US$ 18.15 Disc 1:
|
|
Bach: Cello Suites / Pablo Casals US$ 18.78 Description Not Available |
|
Bach: Cello Suites (Arranged for Saxophone) / Twillert US$ 14.36 Disc 1:
|
|
Bach: Cello Suites - Arranged for Baritone Saxophone US$ 12.15 Disc 1:
|
|
Bach: Cello Suite / Jean-Guihen Queyras US$ 27.21 Disc 1:
|
|
Bach: Cello Suites, BWV 1007-1009 US$ 14.38 Disc 1:
|
|
Bach: Cello Suites Nos. 1-6 US$ 21.36 Description not available. |
|
Bach: Cello Suites no 1, 3 and 5 / Sara Sant`Ambrogio US$ 14.84 Disc 1:
|
|
Music for You - Bach: Cello Suites no 1, 5 & 6 / Yo-Yo Ma US$ 14.46 Description Not Available |
|
Bach: The Cello Suites US$ 12.97 Disc 1:
|
Bach - Cello Suite No.1 i-Prelude
