Beethoven Eroica
Beethoven Eroica
Beethoven's "Eroica" and it's influence?
I've been doing this hw assignment and have found out how beethoven's other symphonies have influenced other 19th century composers..but having trouble finding a 19th century composition that was influenced by Beethoven's Eroica (Symphony no 3)
I think there is a basic misunderstanding to all these questions looking for 'influences'. One point is the general influence an artist exerts on his/her period or the following ones, and in that Beethoven was a great milestone. Another, and quite harder, is to look for the specific influence one work could determine around itself.
First, trying to imitate a work isn't usually what a composer does, except for 'marketing' phenomena like operas in 18th century, for instance, where a lot of me-too' s were produced for selling reasons.
Second, the higher the model, the harder the copy, and Eroica is the top.
Beethoven's Third first movement is the best example of forma sonata, along with Mozart's 40th (Jupiter) and Schubert's Unfinished. Argumenting that they had a mutual influence is like picking classical greek tragedies by Aeschilus and Sophocles and arguing on who influenced whom based on the structural similarities.
If we are referring to a positive, potent, assertive way of exposing bold, clear-cut themes, and working out complex and portentous developments, able to exploit all and every potentiality of the themes, then all the 19th century symphonism had Eroica as a model: Mendelssohn, symphonies 3 Scottish, 4 Italian. Schumann's 3rd. Brahms 2nd.
The same goes with the ability to switch themes over between strings and woodwinds, or the attitude to use dynamics (f, ff, p, pp) to enforce passages.
Or the effect of putting a funeral march directly after the outspoken affirmation of strength and glory of first movement: paradoxically, to revert the effect Mahler's 5th has the Trauermarsch in the beginning.
You have an assignment. I offer you an alternative, writing something like i did above and fencing the thesis off.
If you want to stick to a one liner, pick Schubert's 5th (1816);
12 years after Eroica, bright and assertive.
 |
 MUNCH MONTEUX BSO 8 GREAT SYMPHONIES RCA LIVING STEREO 7 LP BOX SET  US $450.00
|
 FURTWANGLER VPO BEETHOVEN SYMPHONY N°3 Urania URLP 7095 TOP RARITY US $442.60
|
 Wilhelm Furtwaengler Berliner Philharmoniker180 Gram Sealed Vinyl 14LP Box Set US $399.99
|
 Wilhelm Furtwangler Bruckner Schubert Brahms and Wagner Sealed Vinyl 14LP Set US $399.99
|
 STANDARD TREASURY OF THE WORLDS GREAT MUSIC 16 LPs FREE SHIP Classical Strauss US $399.99
|
 Paavo Jarvi Beethoven Symphonies Nos 1 9 180 Gram Sealed Vinyl 9LP Box Set US $379.99
|
 STEREO FOR THE JOY OF IT 10 Classical LPs set RCA LSP 9300 Shaded Dog EX US $300.00
|
 BEETHOVEN Symphony 3 EROICA FURTWANGLER VPO HMV ALP 1060 EXC US $195.00
|
 TIME LIFE STORY CONCERTS OF GREAT MUSIC 18 BOX LP SET US $175.00
|
 KLEMPERER beethoven 3 eroica LP mint UK SAX 2364 US $160.00
|
 APOLLO 10 LP SET DGG DECCA Performances MINT NEW US $149.99
|
 Beethoven 9 Stmphonies Walter on 6 indiviodual covers 6 and 2 eyes stereo US $165.00
|
 LOUGHRAN\HALLE beethoven symphony 5 eroica VAR 1033 LP PS EX EX uk enigma US $144.06
|
 Schuricht Beethoven Symphony No 3 Eroica FALP 574 fine copy US $136.50
|
 COLUMBIA SAX 2364 B S BEETHOVEN EROICA OTTO KLEMPERER PHILHARMONIA US $129.99
|
 MUNCH beethoven eroica sym rca german LSC2233 lp US $125.99
|
 ANTAL DORATI MINNEAPOLIS SYM BEETHOVEN EROICA MERCURY US $120.00
|
 MUNCH BOSTON SYMPHONY BEETHOVEN EROICA RCA LSC2233 US $120.00
|
 THE ART OF FELIX WEINGARTNER Recorded 1931 1940 EMI 3LPs UK US $100.00
|
 LOT OF TWO SWISS ONLY FRITZ BUSCH ALBUMS US $99.99
|
 Audiophile LP EROICA Eterna Collection Beethoven 180g Vinyl Rare SEALED US $99.99
|
 KLEMPERER beethoven no 3 eroica LP mint 35853 1ST US $96.00
|
 PIERRE MONTEUX Beethoven Schubert Brahms Tchaikovsky Debussy Ravel PHILIPS 6 LP US $95.00
|
 TOSCANINI hmv 8904 7x78rpm Set BEETHOVEN Eroica NM US $90.00
|
 Lot 6 Herbert Von Karajan Vinyl Record Albums Brahms Beethoven Tchaikowski G4 US $90.00
|
 Furtwangler VPO Beethoven Eroica Electrola E 90050 US $81.25
|
 FRITZ BUSCH beethoven eroica no 3 LP vinyl RLP 199 21 US $80.00
|
 LEINSDORF beethoven no 3 eroica LP 1A 1D RL 3069 VG US $80.00
|
 FIRST PRESSING KLEMPERER EROICA COLUMBIA AUDIOPHILE REF REC LP US $79.99
|
 Beethoven Op55 Symph No3 E Flat The Eroica Mengelberg 7x 12 78 HMV SET US $79.02
|
 Still Sealed Mint Beethoven Album Everest 3087 US $75.00
|
 VERDI Arias OTHELLO Don Carlos MARIA CALLAS Columbia SAXF 1008 french sax 2550 US $75.00
|
 BEETHOVEN Schumann Piano Sonatas SVIATOSLAV RICHTER HMV ASDF 245 french asd 450 US $75.00
|
 Bernstein Beethoven The Nine Symphonies 8 LP Vinyl Boxed Set Rare US $75.00
|
 WILHELM FURTWANGLER VIENNA PHILHARMONIC BEETHOVEN No3 EROICA 78rpm 12x 3 US $71.13
|
 Music of the Worlds Greatest Composers Box Set 12 Vintage LPS 1959 US $100.00
|
 Beethoven Kempff Karajan Leitner DG DGG Germany STEREO 4xAlbums US $69.99
|
 BEETHOVEN Arturo TOSCANINI Symp No 3 Op 55 RCA LM 1042 US $69.99
|
 KONWITSCHNY Beethoven Symphony 3 ETERN 820 181 MINT US $69.00
|
 Beethoven Ludwig Van Symphonie NR3 Es dur op55 Record and Book Photos Germany US $69.00
|
 SAX 2364 Beethoven No 3 Klemperer NM US $69.00
|
 Artur Rubinstein 1964 RCA Victor Red Seal StillSealed LSC 2733 Beethoven Emperor US $68.88
|
 Eroica Symphony No 3 Beethoven Karl Bohm Heliodor Berlin Philharmonic OrchLP 33 US $67.49
|
 BEETHOVEN Symphony 3 BRUNO WALTER COLUMBIA Philips AY Hi Fi Stereo HOMMAGE v2 US $65.00
|
 Bruno Walter Beethoven Symphony No 3 200 Gram 33rpm Sealed Vinyl LP OOP US $64.99
|
 Beethoven Eroica Kleiber Decca Wide Band Gold LXT2546 US $63.23
|
 WILHELM FURTWANGLER BEETHOVEN Sinfonie NR 3 EROICA ODEON GERMANY US $60.00
|
 DORATI beethoven eroica no 3 LP vinyl SR 90011 VG FR1 US $60.00
|
 Arthur Fiedler Boston Pops Time Life Great Moments of Music CMPLT 21 LP Set Mint US $59.99
|
 BEETHOVEN Symphony 3 EROICA ABBADO VPO DGG 419 597 1 dig 1987 US $55.00
|
 Emil Gilels recital Beethoven S ta 7 15 Variations DG Digital NM US $55.00
|
 BEETHOVEN EROICA KARAJAN DGG RED STEREO ALLE HER ED1 LP US $55.00
|
 HELIODOR LP 478 072 Beethoven Sym No 3 EROICA Jochum OOP 1960 Germany US $50.99
|
 KARAJAN beethoven eroica LP vinyl SLPM 138 802 VG US $50.00
|
 VLADO PERLEMUTER BEETHOVEN EROICA VARIATIONS LISZT SONATA NIMBUS UK US $50.00
|
 BEETHOVEN SYMPHONY 3 EROICA TOSCANINI RCA VICTOR LM 1042 RED SEAL DG VG NM US $50.00
|
 RARE EROICA KRIPS SWISS MONO TEST PRESSING LP US $49.99
|
 BEETHOVEN Symphony No 3 ARTURO TOSCANNI New SEALED LP US $49.99
|
 DGG 5 LPs BEETHOVEN Symphonies No 1 6 Karajan NM US $49.99
|
 FOUR FRANKLIN MINT 100 GREATEST RECORDINGS OF ALL TIME US $49.99
|
 BEETHOVEN EroicaPastoraleChoral Szell Japan 3LPs w OBI US $49.99
|
 BRUNSWICK AXTL Beethoven Diabelli Eroica Variations CLAUDIO ARRAU 2LP set US $49.99
|
 VG CLASSICAL LP BEETHOVEN EROICA RCA LIVING STEREO LSC 2233 US $49.99
|
 FURTWANGLER Beethoven Symphony No3 EROICA heavy RED ELECTROLA superb MONO SOUND US $49.00
|
 KONWITSCHNY GH LEIPZIG Beethoven Symphony 3 ETERN 820 412 MINT US $49.00
|
 KLEMPERER beethoven symphony no 3 eroica LP VG 35853 US $48.00
|
 Beethoven Eroica Symphony Munch Boston Symphony Record RCA Victor LSC 2233 US $47.99
|
 BRUNO WALTER Beethoven Eroica CSO 200G LP US $47.41
|
 Columbia SAX2000 Beethoven The Complete Symphonies Otto KLEMPERER US $47.41
|
 KARL WINTER ZMO ZURICH MUNICIPAL ORCHESTRA beethoven eroica LP PS EX EX ATL 4042 US $43.52
|
 NEUMARK UTRECHT beethoven symphony no 3 eroica LP PS EX EX Classics club US $43.52
|
 DORATI beethoven eroica no 3 LP vinyl SR 90011 VG FR1 US $43.20
|
 BRAHMS the Piano Concerts POLLINI Boehm Abbado VPO DGG 2707 127 2 LPs US $40.00
|
 DORATI beethoven eroica no 3 LP m ED1 SRW 18047 RFR 1 US $40.00
|
 BRUNO WALTER Beethoven Eroica CSO 200 Gram LP NEW SEALED US $39.99
|
 EARLY UK FURTWANGLER HMV ALP 1060 EROICA LP US $39.99
|
 NEARMINT DECCA SXL 2165 EROICA LP US $39.99
|
 ALLEGRO LP Beethoven Sym No 5 Michael Freedman 60s NM US $39.99
|
 EARLY FURTWANGLER EROICA MONO LP US $39.99
|
 COLUMBIA LP Beethoven Syms 5 4 Bruno Walter Stereo NM US $39.99
|
 FURTWANGLER FURTWÄNGLER BEETHOVEN EROICA OP 55 LP US $39.99
|
 Beethoven Eroica no 3 Berlin Symphony Brunswick 78 RPM US $39.69
|
 TOSCANINI SYMPHONY EROICA RCA VICTOR LM 1042 1950 HI FI US $37.49
|
 ERICH LEINSDORF LP BEETHOVEN EROICA SYMPHONY STEREO US $37.49
|
 Beethoven Sym 3 E Flat Op 55 Eroica Boston Symph Koussevitzky US $35.00
|
 BEETHOVEN Bicentennial Collection Pt 1 Vol 1 5 LP NM US $35.00
|
 Karajan Beethoven Eroica NM LP US $34.99
|
 EMI MFP LP Beethoven Symphony No 6 Steinberg 1967 NM US $34.99
|
 BEETHOVEN Adieux Eroica Friedrich Gulda London dg LP US $34.97
|
 BEETHOVEN SYMPH NO 3 EROICA CARLO M GIULINI DGG sealed US $33.48
|
 BEETHOVEN SKETCHES Pt 1 2 Illustrated in the Pianoforte 12 78 Columbia L1934 US $31.60
|
 SHURA CHERKASSY BEETHOVEN Sonata in C Minor Eroica Variations WRC T271 LP US $30.02
|
 Beethoven Symphoni NRr 3 Eroica Fontana 695 001 KL NM US $30.15
|
 BEETHOVEN MONTEUX 3 IN E FLAT OP 55 EROICA SEALED LP CONCERTGEBOUW US $30.00
|
 L V BEETHOVEN EROICA Sinfonie Nº 3 Es dur op55 RARE GERMANY GONG HI FI US $30.00
|
 BEETHOVEN Eroica Symphony LP NM US $29.99
|
 LUDVIG VAN BEETHOVEN KARAJAN BERLINER PHILHARMONIKER 9 SYMHONIEN 8 LP BOX SET US $29.99
|
|
Beethoven - Eroica (DVD) US$ 23.80 This period drama takes Beethoven fans back to the momentous day on which audiences first heard Eroica--or as it is also known--Symphony No.3. Set in 1804 Vienna, the film follows Beethoven (played convincingly by Ian Hart) as he prepares to unveil his... |
|
Beethoven: Symphony No. 3 `Eroica`; Sibelius: Symphony No. 7 US$ 7.19 Disc 1:
|
|
Beethoven: Symphonie No. 3 "Eroica"; Ouverture "Coriolan" US$ 9.08 Description not available. |
|
Beethoven: Symphony No. 3 "Eroica"; Leonore Overture No. 3 US$ 10.37 Description not available. |
|
Beethoven: Symphonies Nos. 3 "Eroica" & 8 US$ 12.86 Description not available. |
|
Beethoven: Symphony No. 3 "Eroica"; Bernstein: How a Great Symphony Was Written US$ 8.42 Description not available. |
|
Beethoven: Symphony No. 3; Overtures US$ 16.53 Disc 1:
|
|
|
Beethoven: Symphonies Nos. 3 & 4 US$ 16.22 Disc 1:
|
|
Beethoven: Symphony no 3, etc / Haitink, London SO US$ 18.49 Disc 1:
|
|
Best Beethoven 100 US$ 15.12 Disc 1:
|
|
Friedrich Gulda Plays Beethoven, Vol. 1 US$ 15.72 Disc 1:
|
Karajan - Beethoven Symphony No. 3 'Eroica' - Part 1
